Whitmans Pond Fishing Report

4.8 Rating based on 5 Reviews

Expensive Trip Tothe Well

So get back on the water after work and it is calm. So at 5:10pm I am off and after fishing half the cove with a buzzbait I put it down to fish a dock/lily pad area with an ocho. Got a tap but no fish. Swithced to my custom spinnerbait big blade 3/16 oz body. On the 4th cast snap....wtf my rod snapped at the stalk. Bummed and out 80 bucks I move on.

I fished an offshore hump from all sides and depths but no fish. Tried the rise between the main cove and the pond nothing there. Got to the quick dropping slope/grassline and wham!. Got 5lbs pickerel on a crankbait parralel to the line. In the process lost my pliers to the pond and found a crack in the spool of my reel.

Getting dark so I head back to the cove only to have my headlamp come apart. That was it tossed around some lillies with topwater and soft plastic but figured I spent enough for one trip lol. Off the water at 7:30pm. Lures: crankbait both shallow and mid depth,spinnerbait,buzzbait,frog,ocho and small swimbait.

  • Added By: creasekeeper on 09/26/11 05:34 PM
  • Location: Whitmans Pond
  • Report Date: 9/25/2011
  • # of Hotspots: 1
  • # of Photos: 0
  • # of Fish Caught: 1
  • Learn more about Whitmans Pond fishing in our fishing message boards

Report Catches

Whitmans Pond Catch

  • # of Fish Caught: 1
  • Water Type: freshwater
  • Type of Fish: Chain Pickerel
  • Fish Length (Avg): 21 inches
  • Fish Length (Max): 21 inches
  • Bait Type: Crankbait Check Prices
  • Bait Details: Mid depth crankbait straight retrieve.
  • Location Details: Caught of a break/grassline

Report Map

Stay Updated

Sign up for our weekly newsletter to receive New Jersey fishing reports right in your inbox. You'll also receive community updates, invites to try new features and promotions from our partners.

NJ Fish Finder

Social Links